Gram Research analysis of 26 Ecuadorian farmers reveals that farmers grow far more food diversity than they eat: an average of 49 different edible plants and 5 types of livestock, but regularly consume only about half. Farmers grow this diversity primarily for economic reasons (88% of farmers), social and emotional reasons like family traditions (85%), farming benefits (50%), and health concerns (31%), not just for household consumption. This explains why studies often find weak connections between farm diversity and diet diversity.

A new study in Ecuador reveals that small farmers grow about twice as many different crops and animals as they actually eat. Researchers interviewed 26 Indigenous and mestizo farmers and discovered that farmers have many reasons for growing diverse foods beyond just feeding their families. Most grow extra crops to sell for money (88% of farmers), for emotional or social reasons like family traditions (85%), to improve their farming practices (50%), and for health and safety (31%). This research helps explain why simply growing more types of food doesn’t automatically mean families eat more variety. Understanding farmers’ real reasons for their choices could help programs better support both nutrition and farming success.

Key Statistics

A 2026 qualitative study of 26 farmers in highland Ecuador found that farmers cultivated an average of 49 different edible plants and five types of livestock, but regularly consumed only about half of them.

According to research reviewed by Gram, 88% of farmers cited economic reasons for growing diverse crops, 85% cited social or emotional reasons, 50% cited agronomic benefits, and 31% cited health and safety considerations.

A participatory research study of 26 Ecuadorian farmers found that foods were eaten rarely or never because of availability limitations (not available when needed), preparation difficulty, taste preferences, or because they were mainly used for other purposes beyond household consumption.

The Quick Take

  • What they studied: Why do small farmers in Ecuador grow so many different crops and animals when they don’t eat most of them?
  • Who participated: 26 Indigenous and mestizo farmers in highland Ecuador who manage small farms with diverse plants and animals
  • Key finding: Farmers grew an average of 49 different edible plants and 5 types of livestock, but regularly ate only about half of them. The main reasons for growing diversity were economic (88%), social or emotional (85%), farming benefits (50%), and health concerns (31%).
  • What it means for you: If you work with farmers or design nutrition programs, simply encouraging more crop diversity won’t automatically improve what families eat. You need to understand farmers’ actual reasons for their choices, which often involve money, family traditions, and farming health, not just household food needs.

The Research Details

This study used a mixed methods approach, combining interviews with analysis techniques that map how farmers think about their decisions. Researchers conducted activity-based interviews with 26 farmers in highland Ecuador, asking them about what they grow and why. The interviews were analyzed using cognitive mapping, a technique that visualizes how people connect ideas and reasons together, and cultural domain analysis, which identifies shared patterns in how communities think about topics. The research was part of a larger participatory action research program, meaning farmers were active partners in the research process rather than just subjects being studied. This approach allowed researchers to understand not just what farmers do, but their own reasoning and values behind those decisions.

Previous research has shown that when farms have more crop diversity, the families living on those farms don’t always eat more diverse diets. This disconnect has puzzled researchers and program designers. By asking farmers directly why they grow what they grow, this study reveals the missing piece: farmers have multiple, overlapping reasons for their production choices that go far beyond feeding their own families. Understanding these real-world motivations is essential for designing programs that actually work with farmers’ values and priorities rather than against them.

This is a qualitative research study, meaning it focuses on understanding reasons and meanings rather than testing a specific hypothesis with large numbers. The sample size of 26 farmers is appropriate for this type of in-depth interview research. The study’s strength lies in its participatory design, where community researchers conducted interviews, ensuring cultural understanding and trust. The analysis methods used (cognitive mapping and cultural domain analysis) are well-established techniques for understanding how people think. However, because the study was conducted in one specific region of Ecuador with a particular group of farmers, the findings may not apply exactly the same way to farmers in other countries or climates. The study provides rich, detailed insights rather than statistics that can be generalized to all farmers worldwide.

What the Results Show

Farmers in this study cultivated an impressive average of 49 different edible plants and raised five types of livestock. However, they regularly consumed only about half of the plants they grew. The researchers identified four main categories of reasons why farmers grow diversity beyond their own consumption needs. Economic reasons were the most common, mentioned by 88% of participants, including selling crops at markets, generating income, and maintaining crops as a form of savings or investment. Social and emotional reasons were cited by 85% of farmers, including maintaining family traditions, preserving cultural practices, and keeping foods that hold sentimental value. Agronomic reasons, mentioned by 50% of farmers, included growing diverse crops to improve soil health, manage pests naturally, and maintain a resilient farming system. Health and safety reasons were cited by 31% of farmers, including growing foods for medicinal purposes and maintaining food security in case of crop failures.

The study identified specific barriers that prevent farmers from eating the foods they grow. Some foods were eaten rarely or never because they were not always available when needed, were difficult or time-consuming to prepare, didn’t match family taste preferences, or were primarily grown for purposes other than household consumption. This finding is important because it shows that simply having diverse crops available doesn’t guarantee diverse diets. The research also highlighted that farmers’ decision-making is deeply influenced by values beyond practical, cause-and-effect thinking. Social and emotional factors, such as maintaining cultural identity and family heritage, play a major role in what farmers choose to grow, a dimension that previous research has largely overlooked.

This research directly addresses a puzzle in the nutrition and agriculture literature: studies consistently show weak statistical relationships between farm diversity and diet diversity, even though it seems logical that growing more types of food would lead to eating more types of food. Previous research often assumed that farmers make decisions primarily based on practical, economic considerations. This study reveals that assumption is incomplete. By showing that 85% of farmers cite social and emotional reasons for their production choices, the research adds an important cultural and social dimension to our understanding of farmer decision-making. The findings align with emerging research in agricultural development that emphasizes the importance of understanding local values, traditions, and social structures rather than imposing external assumptions about what farmers should do.

This study involved only 26 farmers in one region of highland Ecuador, so the specific findings may not apply exactly the same way to farmers in other countries, climates, or cultural contexts. The study is qualitative, meaning it provides rich descriptions and understanding rather than statistical data that can be generalized to large populations. The interviews were conducted by a community researcher, which is a strength for cultural understanding but may introduce some variation in how questions were asked. The study does not include quantitative data on how much of each crop farmers actually produce or consume, so we cannot calculate exact percentages of production that goes to different uses. Finally, the study captures farmers’ stated reasons at one point in time, but farmers’ motivations may change seasonally or year to year based on economic conditions, weather, or other factors.

The Bottom Line

If you design programs to improve farmer nutrition or support agricultural resilience, recognize that farmers have multiple, valid reasons for their production choices beyond household consumption. Programs are more likely to succeed when they align with farmers’ existing values and motivations, particularly their economic needs, cultural traditions, and farming practices. Rather than simply encouraging farmers to grow more diversity, consider how to strengthen the connections between what they produce and what they eat, while respecting their other production goals. This might include helping farmers process or preserve foods they grow but don’t regularly eat, creating market opportunities for diverse crops, or supporting farming practices that maintain both productivity and cultural values.

This research is most relevant for agricultural development organizations, nutrition programs, government agencies working with farmers, and researchers studying food security. Farmers themselves may find it validating to see their decision-making recognized as complex and thoughtful rather than simply practical. Policymakers should care because programs designed without understanding farmers’ real motivations often fail or have unintended consequences. This research is less directly applicable to individual consumers in wealthy countries, though it provides important context for understanding global food systems and agricultural development.

Changes based on this research would not happen quickly. Aligning programs with farmers’ actual motivations is a long-term process that requires building trust, understanding local contexts, and potentially redesigning how programs operate. Farmers might see benefits within one growing season if programs address specific barriers they mentioned (like difficulty preparing certain foods), but broader changes to farming systems and nutrition outcomes typically take multiple years to become visible.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do farmers grow crops they don’t eat?

Farmers grow diverse crops for multiple reasons beyond household consumption: to earn income (88% of farmers), maintain family traditions and cultural practices (85%), improve their farming systems (50%), and address health or safety concerns (31%). Many crops serve multiple purposes simultaneously.

Does growing more food diversity guarantee better nutrition?

Not automatically. A study of 26 Ecuadorian farmers found they grew 49 different plants but regularly ate only half of them. Barriers like preparation difficulty, taste preferences, and availability limitations prevent people from eating foods they grow, so diversity alone doesn’t ensure diverse diets.

What stops farmers from eating the food they produce?

According to research with 26 farmers, foods go uneaten because they’re not available when needed, are difficult or time-consuming to prepare, don’t match family taste preferences, or are primarily grown for sale or other non-consumption purposes rather than household eating.

How important are emotions and traditions in farming decisions?

Very important. Research shows 85% of farmers cite social and emotional reasons for their production choices, including maintaining family heritage and cultural practices. This dimension is often overlooked in agricultural programs that focus only on economic or practical factors.

How can programs better support farmers’ nutrition?

Programs work better when they align with farmers’ actual motivations and address specific barriers. Rather than just encouraging more diversity, consider helping farmers process foods they grow, creating market opportunities, or supporting farming practices that maintain both productivity and cultural values.

Want to Apply This Research?

  • Track the number of different crops or foods you grow or have access to, and separately track how many you actually eat regularly. Note the reasons you don’t eat certain foods (not available when needed, difficult to prepare, don’t like the taste, grown for other purposes). This creates a personal production-consumption map that shows your own patterns.
  • Identify one food you grow or have access to but rarely eat. Explore one barrier preventing you from eating it (preparation difficulty, availability, taste preference). Make one small change to address that barrier, such as learning a new recipe, preserving it for later use, or trying it prepared differently. Track whether this increases how often you eat that food.
  • Monthly, review your food production and consumption patterns. Note any changes in what you’re growing, what you’re eating, and your reasons for those choices. Track whether removing barriers to eating certain foods actually increases your diet diversity. Also note any social, emotional, or economic reasons driving your production decisions, recognizing that these are valid and important alongside nutrition goals.

This research describes findings from a qualitative study of 26 farmers in highland Ecuador and may not apply identically to farmers in other regions, climates, or cultural contexts. The study provides insights into farmer motivations and decision-making but does not constitute medical or nutritional advice. Individuals seeking to improve their nutrition should consult with healthcare providers or registered dietitians. Agricultural development organizations should adapt these findings to their specific contexts and communities rather than applying them universally.

This research translation is published by Gram Research, the science division of Gram, an AI-powered nutrition tracking app.

Source: Why do Farmers Grow Diversity? Reaching Beyond Own-Consumption and Agricultural Income to Support Food Security and Nutrition. , Food and nutrition bulletin (2026). PubMed 42808505 | DOI
Topics
farm diversity smallholder farmers food security nutrition agricultural production farmer decision-making crop diversity food consumption