Research shows that plant diversity, not microbial communities, is the primary factor that changes bee populations in cities. A study of 32 bee species found that while bacteria and fungi on bees remain stable across different bee types and urban environments, the plants bees visit shift significantly with urbanization. This suggests that cities affect bees mainly by changing which plants are available, rather than by altering the microbes living on bees.
Researchers studied 32 different bee species to understand how their relationships with plants and microbes change in cities versus natural areas. They found that while the bacteria and fungi living on bees stay fairly similar across different bee types, the plants bees visit change dramatically depending on how urban an area is. This matters because bees depend on specific plants for food, and understanding how cities affect these plant-bee partnerships could help us protect bees in urban environments. According to Gram Research analysis, plant diversity appears to be the key factor that distinguishes bee communities in cities from those in wild areas.
Key Statistics
A 2026 study of 32 bee species from five families found that plant associations shifted significantly with urbanization and bee functional traits, while bacterial and fungal diversity remained largely consistent across bee families and urban intensities.
Research examining 32 wild bee species revealed that three bee families (Apidae, Colletidae, and Andrenidae) had richer communities of bacteria and plant associates compared to Halictidae and Megachilidae, though fungal diversity was similar across all families.
According to Gram Research analysis of wild bee microbiomes, plant diversity emerged as the primary factor differentiating bee species in urban landscapes, while microbial communities remained stable across bee lineages and functional groups.
The Quick Take
- What they studied: How the bacteria, fungi, and plants associated with wild bees change across different bee species and in urban versus natural environments.
- Who participated: 32 different bee species from five bee families (Apidae, Megachilidae, Halictidae, Colletidae, and Andrenidae), representing various sizes, living arrangements, and behaviors.
- Key finding: While the microscopic organisms living on bees stay relatively stable across different bee types, the plants bees visit change significantly based on how urban the area is.
- What it means for you: Cities may be changing which plants bees can access, which could affect bee health and food sources. This suggests urban planning that preserves diverse plants could help support bee populations in cities.
The Research Details
Scientists collected samples from 32 bee species representing five different bee families. They used genetic testing methods (16S rRNA, ITS1, and rbcL amplicon sequencing) to identify all the bacteria, fungi, and plants associated with each bee. The bees studied varied in important ways: some were large and others small, some lived alone and others in colonies, some were native to the area and others introduced, and some thrived in cities while others preferred wild areas.
The researchers compared how the microbial communities and plant associations differed between bee families, between bees with different traits (like body size or social behavior), and between urban and natural environments. This approach allowed them to identify which factors most strongly influenced what microbes and plants were associated with each bee species.
By examining multiple genetic markers, the team could identify not just which organisms were present, but also how diverse these communities were across different bee types and environments.
This research design is important because it looks at real bees in real environments rather than studying bees in laboratories. By examining multiple bee families with different characteristics, the researchers could determine whether patterns were universal across all bees or specific to certain types. This helps us understand whether changes in urban areas affect all bees similarly or whether some bee species are more affected than others.
The study examined a substantial number of bee species (32) from multiple families, which strengthens the findings. The use of genetic sequencing methods provides objective identification of microbes and plants rather than relying on visual observation. However, the study does not specify the exact number of individual bees sampled from each species, which would help assess the robustness of the results. The research was published in a peer-reviewed scientific journal, indicating it underwent expert review.
What the Results Show
The research revealed that bacterial and fungal communities living on bees are remarkably consistent across different bee families and functional groups. Three bee families (Apidae, Colletidae, and Andrenidae) had richer communities of bacteria and plants compared to the other two families (Halictidae and Megachilidae), but fungal diversity was similar across all families.
The most striking finding was that plant associations changed significantly based on urbanization and functional traits of bees, while microbial communities remained stable. This means that as you move from natural areas to cities, the plants bees visit shift noticeably, but the bacteria and fungi on the bees do not change as much.
Certain bacteria and plant associations were found across many bee species, suggesting these are common partnerships in bee communities. However, some microbes and plants were unique to specific bee species, indicating specialized relationships have evolved in some cases.
The researchers concluded that plant diversity is the primary factor that distinguishes bee communities in urban landscapes from those in wild areas, suggesting that urban plant availability is a key driver of bee community composition.
The study found that bee body size, nesting behavior, whether bees live alone or in colonies, and their native status all influenced which plants they associated with. Bees that were native to an area had different plant partnerships than introduced species. The diversity of plant associations was more sensitive to these functional traits than bacterial or fungal diversity was, indicating that plants are the most variable component of bee ecosystems.
Previous research has shown that bee microbiomes are influenced by diet and environment, but this study provides new evidence that plant associations are more variable than microbial communities across bee species. This finding suggests that earlier studies focusing primarily on microbial diversity may have missed the more important role of plant availability in shaping bee communities. The stability of microbial communities across bee types aligns with some previous work suggesting that core microbial communities are conserved in bees.
The study does not specify how many individual bees were sampled from each species, which limits our ability to assess whether the findings are based on a few bees or many bees per species. The research examines only wild bees and does not include honeybees, so findings may not apply to managed bee populations. The study was conducted in specific geographic locations, so results may differ in other regions with different plant communities and urban patterns. Additionally, the research is correlational, meaning it shows which organisms and plants are associated with bees but cannot definitively prove that urbanization causes the observed changes in plant associations.
The Bottom Line
Urban planners and gardeners should prioritize planting diverse native plants in cities to support bee populations. This recommendation has moderate to strong support from this research. Efforts to preserve natural areas with diverse plant communities near cities may help maintain healthy bee populations. Conservation efforts should focus on protecting plant diversity rather than assuming that microbial communities are the limiting factor for bee health.
City planners, gardeners, conservation organizations, and anyone interested in supporting urban bee populations should pay attention to these findings. Researchers studying bee ecology and urban ecology will find this work particularly relevant. People living in cities who want to help bees through gardening should focus on growing diverse plants. This research is less directly applicable to beekeepers managing honeybees, as the study focused on wild bees.
Changes in bee communities in response to increased plant diversity in urban areas would likely take multiple growing seasons to become apparent, probably 1 to 3 years. Individual bees would begin visiting new plants as soon as they become available, but population-level changes would take longer to measure.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do cities change the bacteria living on bees?
No, research on 32 bee species shows bacterial and fungal communities on bees remain stable across urban and natural environments. Instead, cities primarily change which plants bees can access, affecting their food sources rather than their microbial partners.
What is the most important factor affecting bees in cities?
Plant diversity is the primary factor differentiating bee communities in urban areas. A study of 32 bee species found that plant associations change significantly with urbanization, while microbial communities stay relatively constant across different bee types.
How can I help urban bees based on this research?
Plant diverse native plants that bloom at different times of year. Since plant availability is the key factor affecting urban bee communities, increasing plant diversity in gardens and green spaces directly supports bee populations in cities.
Are all bee species affected equally by city environments?
No, different bee species show different plant associations in cities. The study found that bee body size, nesting behavior, and whether bees live alone or in colonies influence which plants they visit, meaning urbanization affects different bee types differently.
Do bees in cities have different microbes than wild bees?
Research on 32 bee species shows microbial diversity and composition are similar across urban and natural environments. The bacteria and fungi on bees remain stable regardless of urbanization, suggesting microbes are not the primary way cities affect bees.
Want to Apply This Research?
- Track the number of different plant species flowering in your garden or local area each month, noting which bee species visit each plant. This creates a personalized record of how plant diversity correlates with bee visits.
- If you have outdoor space, plant 3 to 5 native plant species that bloom at different times of year. Use the app to photograph and identify which bees visit these plants over the growing season, building a record of your local bee-plant partnerships.
- Maintain a seasonal log of plant blooming times and bee visits across multiple years. This long-term data helps you understand whether increasing plant diversity in your area correlates with more diverse bee visits, directly testing the study’s findings in your own environment.
This research examines wild bee species and their associations with plants and microbes in urban versus natural environments. The findings do not constitute medical or health advice for humans. While the research suggests that plant diversity supports bee populations, individual results may vary based on local climate, geography, and plant availability. Consult with local conservation experts or native plant societies for specific recommendations for your region. This study is observational and cannot prove that urbanization directly causes changes in plant associations, only that these changes correlate with urbanization. Always follow local regulations regarding planting and bee conservation efforts.
This research translation is published by Gram Research, the science division of Gram, an AI-powered nutrition tracking app.