Gram Research analysis shows that replacing 50% of molasses with cactus juice in dairy cow nutrient blocks increased feed intake and milk production in a 16-cow Ethiopian study. Cows receiving the 50% replacement treatment produced the most milk while maintaining similar milk quality to cows fed all-molasses blocks. This suggests cactus juice could be a practical, locally available alternative to expensive molasses for farmers in dryland regions, though more research is needed to confirm long-term effects.
Researchers in Ethiopia tested whether cactus juice could replace expensive molasses in special nutrient blocks fed to dairy cows. The study involved 16 crossbred cows that received different versions of these blocks over 60 days. When molasses was partially replaced with cactus juice, cows ate more of the blocks and produced more milk. The findings suggest that cactus, a plant that grows well in dry areas, could be a cheaper and more available alternative to molasses for farmers in dryland regions. However, the study was small and lasted only two months, so more research is needed to confirm these results.
Key Statistics
A randomized controlled trial of 16 crossbred dairy cows in Ethiopia found that replacing 50% of molasses with cactus cladode juice in nutrient blocks increased milk yield compared to blocks containing only molasses, published in 2026.
According to research reviewed by Gram, cows fed nutrient blocks with 50% cactus juice replacement consumed more of the blocks and showed the highest feed utilization efficiency compared to 0%, 75%, and 100% replacement levels.
A 60-day study of dairy cows found that while estimated total methane production increased with higher cactus juice inclusion, methane emission intensity per kilogram of milk decreased, suggesting improved feed efficiency.
Milk composition including fat and protein content remained similar across all four treatment groups in the cactus juice replacement study, indicating that the type of sweetener in nutrient blocks does not significantly affect milk quality.
The Quick Take
- What they studied: Whether cactus juice could work as well as molasses in nutrient blocks that farmers feed to dairy cows, and how this affects milk production and cow digestion.
- Who participated: Sixteen mid-lactation dairy cows that were crossbreeds of local Zebu cattle and Holstein Friesian cattle in Ethiopia. The cows were divided into four groups that received different versions of the nutrient blocks.
- Key finding: Cows that received blocks with 50% cactus juice and 50% molasses ate the most feed and produced the most milk. Cows eating more cactus juice produced slightly more methane gas during digestion, but the amount of methane per unit of milk produced actually decreased.
- What it means for you: If you are a farmer in a dry region with limited access to molasses, cactus juice could be a practical and affordable way to make nutrient blocks for your dairy cows. However, this is preliminary evidence from a small study, so you should monitor your own cows’ performance if you try this approach.
The Research Details
Researchers divided 16 dairy cows into four equal groups. Each group received a different version of urea-multi-nutrient blocks, which are compressed blocks of feed that contain protein and minerals. The blocks differed in how much molasses was replaced with cactus cladode juice: one group got 0% replacement (all molasses), another got 50% replacement, a third got 75% replacement, and the last group got 100% replacement (all cactus juice, no molasses). The cows were given 14 days to adjust to their new feed, then researchers measured how much each cow ate, how much milk it produced, and the quality of that milk for 60 days. Researchers also estimated how much methane gas each cow produced during digestion based on the type of feed consumed.
This research approach is important because it tests a practical solution to a real problem farmers face. Molasses is expensive and hard to find in dry regions, so finding a local alternative could help small farmers improve their dairy production. By testing different replacement levels (50%, 75%, and 100%), the researchers could identify the best balance between cost savings and milk production. The study also measured methane emissions because reducing livestock methane is important for the environment.
This study was a randomized controlled trial, which is a strong research design where cows were randomly assigned to different treatment groups. The researchers used a block design, meaning they grouped similar cows together before assigning them to treatments, which helps make the results more reliable. However, the study had limitations: only 16 cows were tested, which is a small number, and the study lasted only 60 days, which is relatively short for measuring long-term effects. The researchers themselves noted that direct methane measurements would be needed to confirm their estimates.
What the Results Show
The 50% replacement treatment, where half the molasses was replaced with cactus juice, produced the best results overall. Cows in this group ate the most nutrient blocks and produced the most milk. The milk composition, meaning the levels of fat, protein, and other nutrients in the milk, was very similar across all four treatment groups, suggesting that the type of sweetener in the blocks did not significantly affect milk quality. As more cactus juice was added to the blocks, cows ate slightly less of the total feed, and milk production decreased slightly. The researchers estimated that cows eating more cactus juice produced more total methane gas, which makes sense because they were eating more plant material that ferments in their stomachs.
An important secondary finding was that even though cows eating more cactus juice produced more total methane, the amount of methane produced per kilogram of milk actually decreased. This means the cows were becoming more efficient at converting feed into milk. The efficiency of converting nutrient blocks into milk was highest in the 50% replacement group, suggesting this mixture provided the best balance of nutrition and palatability, or how much the cows liked eating it.
This study adds to growing evidence that cactus can be used as livestock feed in dry regions. Previous research has shown that cactus is nutritious for cattle and grows well in areas where other feed crops struggle. This research is novel because it specifically tests cactus juice as a replacement for molasses in compressed nutrient blocks, which is a practical application for smallholder farmers. The finding that 50% replacement works best aligns with other research suggesting that partial substitutions often work better than complete replacements.
The study had several important limitations. Only 16 cows were tested, which is a small number that limits how much we can generalize the findings to other herds. The study lasted only 60 days, which is relatively short for measuring effects on milk production and composition. The researchers estimated methane emissions based on feed type rather than measuring it directly from the cows, so the methane results are less reliable than they would be with direct measurement. The study was conducted in one specific region of Ethiopia with one type of crossbred cow, so results may not apply to other regions or cattle breeds. The researchers did not measure the cost savings or long-term sustainability of using cactus juice.
The Bottom Line
Farmers in dryland regions with access to cactus plants may consider replacing 50% of the molasses in their nutrient blocks with cactus juice. This level of replacement appears to maintain milk production while potentially reducing costs. Start by testing this approach on a small portion of your herd and monitor milk production and cow health closely. Do not switch to 100% cactus juice replacement based on this study, as milk production declined at higher replacement levels. Moderate confidence in these recommendations: the study was well-designed but small and short-term.
This research is most relevant to smallholder dairy farmers in dry regions where molasses is expensive or unavailable and cactus grows naturally or can be easily cultivated. It may be particularly useful in sub-Saharan Africa and other dryland areas with similar climates. Farmers in regions with abundant, cheap molasses may not benefit from this change. Large-scale commercial dairy operations may find the cost savings less significant than small farmers would. Environmental advocates interested in reducing livestock methane emissions should note that while total methane increased, methane per unit of milk decreased, suggesting improved efficiency.
If you implement this change, you should expect to see effects on milk production within 2 to 4 weeks as your cows adjust to the new feed. The full benefits in terms of cost savings and consistent milk production would likely become apparent over 2 to 3 months of feeding. However, this study only lasted 60 days, so longer-term effects beyond this timeframe are unknown.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can cactus juice replace molasses in livestock feed blocks?
Cactus juice can partially replace molasses in nutrient blocks. A 16-cow study found that 50% replacement maintained milk production while potentially reducing costs. Complete replacement (100%) reduced milk yield, so partial replacement appears to be the best approach.
Does feeding cactus juice to dairy cows affect milk quality?
No significant difference in milk composition was observed across different levels of cactus juice replacement in this study. Milk fat and protein content remained similar whether cows received blocks with molasses, cactus juice, or a mixture of both.
How much methane do cows produce when fed cactus juice blocks?
Estimated total methane production increased with more cactus juice in the diet, but methane per kilogram of milk produced actually decreased, indicating the cows became more efficient at converting feed to milk.
What percentage of molasses replacement works best for dairy cows?
A 50% replacement of molasses with cactus juice produced the best results in this study, with cows eating more of the blocks and producing more milk compared to other replacement levels tested.
Is cactus juice a practical feed alternative for dryland farmers?
Cactus juice shows promise as a locally available, cost-effective alternative to molasses in dryland regions where molasses is expensive or scarce. However, this was a small, short-term study, so farmers should test it on a portion of their herd first.
Want to Apply This Research?
- Track daily milk production in liters and milk composition (fat and protein percentage if available) for each cow receiving the modified nutrient blocks. Compare these measurements to your baseline from before making the switch. Record the amount of nutrient blocks consumed daily and the cost per block to calculate your actual savings.
- If using a livestock management app, log the date you switch to 50% cactus juice replacement blocks and record which cows receive this feed. Set a reminder to weigh or visually assess cactus cladode availability in your region monthly to ensure consistent supply. Track any changes in cow behavior, appetite, or health that might indicate the new feed is working well.
- Over the first 3 months, monitor milk yield and composition weekly if possible, or at minimum every 2 weeks. Keep records of cactus juice preparation costs versus molasses costs to calculate actual savings. If you notice milk production dropping below your baseline after 4 weeks, consider adjusting back to a higher molasses percentage. Continue monitoring for at least 6 months to identify any long-term effects not captured in this 60-day study.
This research is preliminary and based on a small study of 16 cows over 60 days in one region of Ethiopia. Results may not apply to all cattle breeds, regions, or farming systems. Before making changes to your livestock feeding program, consult with a veterinarian or animal nutritionist familiar with your local conditions. The methane estimates in this study were calculated, not directly measured, so actual emissions may differ. Individual cow responses to dietary changes vary, so monitor your animals closely when introducing new feeds. This information is for educational purposes and should not replace professional agricultural or veterinary advice.
This research translation is published by Gram Research, the science division of Gram, an AI-powered nutrition tracking app.